CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Corrected Feb. 8, 2012 – 11:40 a.m.
Squabbling Starts Over Payroll Tax
By Sam Goldfarb, CQ Staff
Negotiators working to extend a payroll tax cut and two other politically sensitive measures expiring at the end of the month expressed cautious optimism Tuesday that they will reach a bipartisan agreement.
But with the House and Senate conferees showing little progress and the deadline in sight, Senate Democratic leaders have grown impatient and are threatening to move new legislation.
Majority Whip
“I mean, just take a look at it. We’re going to be here next week. We have a week break. Then what, one more week back in before the deadline? So, we’re pushing on the door here,” said Durbin, D-Ill.
A two-month extension (PL 112-78) was enacted in December, and Durbin said another stopgap may be needed. “I hope it doesn’t get to that,” he said. “We can’t lurch every 60 days into another threat of the economy being damaged by our inability to reach an agreement.”
But Senate Finance Chairman
“We will find a solution that has quite significant bipartisan agreement — about that I’m sure,” the Montana Democrat said.
Baucus said negotiators are inching forward on the most divisive issue before them, having begun talking behind the scenes about how to pay for the legislative package, which could cost as much as $160 billion over 10 years.
And Democrats on the conference committee are preparing to make an offer to Republicans regarding unemployment benefits. The proposal, which could be made as early as Wednesday, would address unresolved questions including how many weeks benefits would be paid and whether recipients should have to meet education requirements.
The looming expiration of federal unemployment benefits and the payroll tax cut is probably the biggest issue facing Congress this month, with members of both parties eager to extend the programs for both economic and political reasons. Lawmakers also want to extend the so-called doc fix before its expiration on March 1 triggers cuts in payment to doctors treating Medicare patients.
Leaders of both parties have expressed increased anxiety in recent days about the progress of the conference. Calling Republicans intransigent, Senate Majority Leader
GOP leaders, including House Speaker
Michigan Republican
Squabbling Starts Over Payroll Tax
“I don’t think the comments from either side of leadership, from either body are particularly helpful,” Camp said.
Little Progress in Public
The conferees met in a fourth public session Tuesday, with discussion focused on cost offsets proposed by Republicans, such as extending a pay freeze for lawmakers and federal workers and increasing Medicare premiums. For the most part, Democrats expressed strong opposition to the proposals.
Camp said the GOP offsets would cover $70 billion of the cost of the extensions.
Charging upper-income seniors higher monthly premiums for Medicare doctor care and prescription drugs was billed as saving $31 billion over 10 years. But Democrats said that over time, middle-income Medicare participants would end up paying more.
Freezing the pay of members of Congress and federal workers through 2013 would save an estimated $26 billion, according to Republicans. Democrats said that would be unfair to federal workers and harm the government’s ability to attract talent.
And another offset, worth $13.4 billion, would require those obtaining health insurance through exchanges under the 2010 health care law (PL 111-148, PL 111-152) to repay more of their subsidies if their annual income exceeds estimated amounts. Democrats said the repayment requirement has already been increased twice, and that another increase would discourage use of the exchanges.
Sources told CQ HealthBeat that the search for offsets for the doc fix portion of the package may now shift to Medicare payments to hospitals.
The House-passed version of the bill would aim to save $10.6 billion by trimming Medicare payments to hospitals for patients who do not pay their out-of-pocket charges. Another House provision would save $6.8 billion by reducing payments for outpatient services.
The cost of the current two-month extension of the payroll tax cut, unemployment benefits and doc fix is being offset by a 10-year fee increase paid by mortgage lenders on home loans bought by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
On Tuesday, Sen.
CQ HealthBeat Editor John Reichard, Niels Lesniewski and Alan K. Ota contributed to this story.
First posted Feb. 7, 2012 3:26 p.m.
Correction
Corrected the party affiliation of Rep. Dave Camp, R-Mich., and a quote from Sen. Bob Corker, R-Tenn.